| 
       From the Drawing 
      Board 
      (occasional ramblings of a Small Craft 
      Designer) 
       
      by JohnWelsford 
       
      Mr. Bolger would laugh 
      his socks off... 
      As a New Zealander with a passionate interest in sailing, 
      I drive through Auckland with one eye on the road and one on the sea, and 
      of late I even make detours and sit on the clifftops of North Shore City 
      where the parks and beaches overlook the Hauraki Gulf where the Americas 
      Cup contenders will be racing in a few weeks time.  
      Yesterday there were five pairs of the distinctive sails 
      with their attendant fizzboat wakes out there, and when later in the day I 
      pulled into Halsey St. where the challengers bases are, the activity was 
      like an anthill that had been well stirred with a stick. The pressure is 
      on, Team New Zealand has launched the first of their two boats, and will 
      be sailing her very soon. The rumours are flying as to a new breakthrough 
      in design, possibly a new type of rig, odd shapes underwater, strange 
      keels and odd winglets and fins. All top secret, all big bucks, and so far 
      beyond the aspirations of the likes of us that it hardly seems related to 
      reality at all. 
      But while sitting chatting to one of the senior members in 
      a challenger compound that has to remain nameless ( I'm on good enough 
      terms with the troops to get into some of these places, but the boss had 
      better not know I'm there) I noted that the shapes of most of the boats is 
      actually very simple. The odd bumps and hollows of years past seem to have 
      disappeared in this generation of boats, while the keels, ballast bulbs 
      and rudders are sprouting odd little fins and wings the hulls actually 
      have a very strong resemblance to some of our simple plywood hulls. Mr. 
      Bolger would laugh his socks off and drag out the plans for the old "Black 
      Skimmer". 
      Many point to the excesses of The Americas Cup and witter 
      on about the "waste" of money ( we have a name for this sort of thing 
      here, we call it a "Woftam" - this means a "Waste Of F (you know the word) 
      Time And Money). But there are some interesting things to be gained from 
      the research and development. Even our simple plywood sharpie shapes are 
      able to be improved, and tank testing is not something most of us have 
      access to so a few minutes spent carefully eyeballing a shape that has 
      cost millions to develop, and half an hour with binoculars watching a boat 
      sailing can give a designer like me a years worth of experiments to do. 
      Now I don't have a test tank, but do have one of the best 
      tow testing sites I know of. Lake Rotorua about 10 minutes walk from home 
      discharges through a weir about 12 meters wide and a meter deep. The water 
      speed through there is around five knots and the lake bottom for several 
      hundred yards out into the lake shelves very slowly into deeper water and 
      the bottom is almost perfectly smooth giving a waterflow with very little 
      turbulence. I trial hull models in there with a video camera, a big 
      surfcasters fishing rod, a very delicate spring balance and a long rod 
      marked off in tenths of a meter in the same scale as the hull model. 
      How I go about this is I build a model, some would call it 
      crude, I call it appropriately simple, all is has to do is give me an 
      accurate scale representation of the underwater shape, and it has to have 
      a consistent surface finish so that a series of models will not have their 
      results skewed by one having a surface finish with more drag than another. 
      The model is then fitted with the scale marked rod along the centreline 
      and ballasted to its design waterline. 
      Next, I get out my fishermans waders and head off down to 
      the lake exit very early in the morning or last thing on a calm night, 
      wander around in thigh deep water with my hand held boat speedo until I 
      find the speed range I want, then go about 20 paces upstream and drive a 
      spike with a fishing rod holder into the lake floor. 
      The rod is perfectly ordinary, it has 20lb monofilament 
      nylon line on the reel, but I have a very delicate spring balance in 
      between the reel and the first guide. The idea being that by taping the 
      line to the balance I can measure the pull. By undoing the tape and 
      letting out more line I can let the model back into faster water closer to 
      the weir and take another reading. 
      I puzzled over speed reading for a while, messing about 
      with means of measuring speeds and movement, but came to the conclusion 
      that it was Speed / Length Ratios (S/L) that I wanted, and by putting the 
      marked rod along the centreline of the boat and noting the spacing of the 
      peaks of the wave train in the wake, I could determine the S/L ratio and 
      compare them with the balance readings. An hour or so in the soft light of 
      a summer dawn can give me twenty or more readings over S/L ratios from 0.5 
      to 1.5 and I can go home to breakfast with enough data to keep me puzzling 
      for a day or two while I run the videos and compare the results with 
      graphs made on other days with other models. 
      I am also a bit of a petrol head, having raced motorcycles 
      and cars in the past. There is a very true saying that "you can take the 
      boy out of the racer, but not the racer out of the boy" . Throughout the 7 
      or 8 months of the season I sit up every second Sunday night watching the 
      Formula One racing cars shriek around circuits on the other side of the 
      world.  
      Now what on earth is this turkey on about I hear the 
      voices say! This emag is about us amateurs building little boats not mega 
      million dollar racecars and even more expensive boats. 
      I am old enough to remember driving cars with cable 
      brakes, cars that would slide off the road and fall or roll over at the 
      slightest provocation. The car I drive today has four wheel hydraulic disk 
      brakes with an antilock system, fully independent suspension, amazingly 
      grippy radial ply tyres. It uses half the fuel at much faster cruising 
      speeds than I could have achieved with my first car, and is hugely safer 
      in an accident than the old one. Many of these improvements were pioneered 
      in racing cars, cars that at the time seemed to have no relevance to our 
      day to day reality, and so with the boats. 
      The IACC ( International Americas Cup Class) boats are 
      magnificent, their speed upwind and their ability to manoeuvre, to 
      maintain speed through a tack or gybe, their resistance to pitching, and 
      their use of high tech materials is a testing arena similar in relevance 
      to our pottering about on lakes and bays as the Formula One racing car is 
      to our commuting in to work each day. 
      As a designer, I have to believe that I can produce 
      something a little better today than yesterday. If not, then I may as well 
      just tell people to go buy a copy of John Gardners Dory Book. So I 
      actively pursue improvements both to the boats and to my knowledge of how 
      they work, and for me one of the many challenges I face is to adapt and to 
      make relevant to "our world" some of the information being generated by 
      the many millions of dollars being spent on those incredible boats now 
      sailing Aucklands outer harbour. 
      
      John Welsford Small Craft Design. 
      jwboatdesigns@xtra.co.nz  
       |